By Ian McInnes
It is good to see the new development in Dulwich Village, on the old S G Smith garage and motor repair site, finally coming to completion - a few weeks over nine years since planning permission was first granted on 14 July 2015. It was designed for the Dulwich Estate and S G Smith by Panter Hudspith, the architects for the Estate’s recent GP surgery, shop and residential building in Croxted Road. The original scheme had 12 units made up of four four-bedroom houses, four five-bedroom houses, three ‘affordable‘ one-bedroom apartments and one ‘affordable’ wheelchair accessible three-bedroom house. Car parking was in the basement, accessed from Gilkes Place.
Planning consent was granted, despite nearly 500 objections from local residents. The site was then sold to a housing developer, McCulloch Homes, for £5.25m. They called the development ‘The Gilkes’ and decided to use their own architects to develop the detailed design. They also tried unsuccessfully to have the social housing provision removed but did gain approval to some detail design amendments. Unfortunately, by the time work was due to start, the financial situation, exacerbated by the Covid shutdowns in 2020, meant that, other than demolition, nothing was happening. McCulloch Homes subsequently sold the site on to Aquinna Homes in 2021 - they changed the development’s name to ‘Soane Place’ and have built out the scheme over the last three years. They also managed to remove the affordable housing requirement. The sales brochure appeared to target wealthy overseas investors, whereas you would have thought that the most likely purchasers already live locally or are families moving to the area for the schools.
The completed scheme is similar to the consented one. The five-bedroom homes have been lost, but the overall number of units remains the same. While the row of gable roofs is not something that is typical Dulwich, the houses fit in well in the street context and the overall massing responds to the scale of the surrounding houses, tall in the middle and lower at each end - although the section over the entrance to the underground car park and opposite the Village Hall is fussier and less successful. Construction is traditional brick and block with projecting precast reconstituted stone bays, bronze aluminium windows, and tiled, artificial slate, sloping roofs. All units also have photovoltaic solar panels. Money has been spent on the external works, particularly the front steps and railings. Closer examination reveals slightly clunky detailing in the reconstructed stone panels and parapets, some crude lead flashings, and an annoying offset of the down pipes on the front and rear elevations. The specification of the interior finishes is high, as you would expect for the price. Nearly every bedroom has an ensuite, while the larger houses have underfloor heating (with air-conditioning in some rooms). All units have door entry, security and sprinkler systems.
Overall, the development is clearly a considerable improvement on the old brick and metal-clad workshops that used to be on the site. While some will argue that apartments for elderly downsizers might have been a better option on the site and the lack of ‘affordable’ housing is unfortunate, the result is certainly an enhancement to the centre of the Village and the builder should be given credit for building the scheme out without major disruption to the local area.